I finally had enough. I mean, how many times do I have to answer same question? I wasn’t frustrated with the students...I was frustrated with myself. His furrowed brow and clenched fist told the whole story. “How do you expect me to do this when you’re not here to help me? It’s so easy to do it when I watch you do the example. But when I’m at home doing the work by myself...oy!” Admittedly, since this frustration first emerged a few years ago I’ve morphed my homework practice a bit: not as many problems and more of them done in class with me there to help. But, still, they do have some work to complete on their own.
My response remained constant: “Take good notes!” ... “Call a math buddy!” Unsatisfactory.
I decided to take a swing at delivering a better answer. To make a long story short (I’ll deliver the longer story over a series of shorter posts), I devised a way to record my pen strokes on a tablet PC using my Toshiba Tablet, my Macbook Pro, and Pinnacle’s hardware/software for Mac. I then recorded my voice using Garageband, and synced the two in iMovie, then uploaded them to my Youtube channel for the students to access, and embedded them on my website.
The Verdict
I uploaded my first set of Youtube notes for my Advanced Algebra class a little over two years ago. Surprisingly, my inbox housed positive responses from my students and from students in other classes, students enrolled in home study, students that tried to keep current with the class while vacationing, and high school and college students in other states. Thankfully, my work with Youtube notes, Message Boards on my website, student projects and utilizing cable content earned some recognition this year with the Cable Industry, but I’m still not completely satisfied.
The Problem
I have not yet mastered the art of capturing everything that occurs in class in a slidedeck that is meant to stand apart from the interactions that drive our classroom discussions from time to time. Typically, the slidedecks I use in class are a bit different than what I deliver in these videos. For example, today I took my classes outside and we measured some distances and then calculated some observations in groups. How do I translate that effectively using this tablet PC? Yeah, I tried taping our activities but it just doesn’t work for the one student watching at home. There might be a clever way around that, but I haven’t figured it out.
My Honest Assessment
I feel like I can do a better job, but not sure exactly how to accomplish that. I’ve tried different formulas but keep returning to where I am right now. Maybe the recognition is because I’m the first one trying it (that I know of, anyway), and not necessarily the one that’s perfected it. For the record, though, I’m just happy to be part of the journey. Self-criticism aside, I feel like it's opened up learning opportunities for a lot of my students that need a pause/rewind button without the embarrassment that's tied with hitting those buttons too many times in a classroom full of your peers. I'll cover the reflections a little bit more in depth in future posts.
I usually make each video at the end of the day, and they take about 15 minutes each to make, with about a 30 minute upload time each, for a grand total of 90 minute a day from start to finish, with only 40 of those minutes involving me sitting in front of a computer. With the time consideration, and the fact that I want my family to remember my face by the weekend, I usually skip over some of the fancier post-production luxuries that the Adobe suite or Final Cut Studio afford me.
This is where you come in: I want to make these better and would love some feedback. Give me some ideas that I can run with that don’t involve me forfeiting meals or sleep.
So, what’s the goal then?
The goal isn’t necessarily to recreate the classroom environment, but to give students that might be stuck on a concept in a problem access to help anytime in a digital environment. That said, these videos might not be burning up the Youtube charts, but they serve the purpose that I want them to serve.
So What Next?
In the next few days I will be posting how and why I do it, alternatives to this method (Jing, Smarboards, etc.), and some reflections after two years of delivering content through Youtube. In the meantime, here are a couple of videos that are fairly representative of what I’m doing (please excuse the goofy voice, and blatant copyright infringements):
Ellipses:
Parabolas
It's great to see someone else trying to nail down this idea of allowing kids to look at examples online. (it looks like we're right up the road from each other...I'm in Porterville) I have been working on this for the last three years. It is definitely a work in progress. Here is some of the work I have done. http://bit.ly/EkXQr
ReplyDeleteThe one thing I can suggest is getting a hold of Camtasia Studio. it allows you to record and talk at the same time and then you can produce the video in multiple formats.
I really like the cleanliness of your recordings. Your slides are sharp and easy to follow. For mine, the original problem is usually typed in, but all of my work is freehand. Still looking for a neater way to do it.
Glad I found your blog.
Hey bud,
ReplyDeletePorterville! We have friends that live there and my wife's grandparents lived there for quite some time before they passed away. It's a small world.
Thanks for suggesting Camtasia Studio. The beauty of blogging. I've never heard of Camtasia but will have to give it a try. The problem I'm running into with my current format is that I can't seem to find a replacement tablet (and I need one..badly) that has a video out jack of any type.
With Camtasia, can you write over any program, or only in the program that comes with it? I like how you've tied different videos to standards, and how you are able to capture some of the mojo of the classroom by recording "live."
Hopefully our dialogue can expand once I start elaborating on the current setup.
Take care...
Small world, indeed. Camtasia Studio is the screen capture software I use. It is made by TechSmith (makers of Jing). When I record, it goes something like this: Set up the problems in SmartNotebook, put on the mic, use my Qomo tablet to annotate and hit record in Camtasia. I have been rendering the video in Mv4 (iPod) format and then I upload to my channel on blip.tv (coxmath.blip.tv). The blip channel automatically syncs with my podcast in iTunes (coxmath) so kids are watching these things on their iPods/iPhones and I even had a kid tell me he watches examples on his PSP. Overall time is about 45 minutes. It takes me about 10 minutes to set up the problems, 20 minutes to record all the examples, video renders in about 10 minutes and it takes no more than 5 to upload to blip.
ReplyDeleteThe Qomo tablet does come with it's own annotation software, but I prefer Smart, so I use it. Camtasia does nothing but record and render the video.
The live recording is how it all started and putting it to standards just made sense to me at the time. I also organized them according to book section. I posted about the evolution of my process here: http://wp.me/pusUd-4n
Thanks for the ideas. I just found an option in my Smartboard software that allows me to export the slides in the notebook software into .ppt format. Might be just what I was looking for to get what I'm using in class back onto my tablet. Thanks for the heads up on blip tv and iTunes. I might need to investigate posting from that angle as well. If I make a switch I will have to stay there because between uploading to Youtube and then possibly to one more site that could take quite a while.
ReplyDeleteTake care!
If you have a smartboard, why don't you just record using the smart recorder? Heck, you could record while writing on your board in the front of the room. I am not familiar with how the tablet pc's work, but you may be able to save a step or two. If you attach a mic, you can talk while your are writing and save yourself a bunch of time.
ReplyDeleteFunny you should ask that. My Smartboard is new to me and I'm not familiar with how to attach a microphone. My understanding is that Smarttech offers an optional wireless headset that you can connect to facilitate the voice recordings. Do I even need that special headset?
ReplyDeleteAlso, I've seen in a few blogs that the file format it converts the video to is native to the Smarboard software only. Is that right? Some folks said they have trouble converting the file format into something a bit more share-friendly.
I would love to be able to use the Smartboard to do it so I can cut those middle steps you're talking about.
Thanks again for the help...
I use a wireless mic that I picked up at Radio Shack. I plug it into the computer because that is what is actually doing the recording. My SmartBoard recording is a windows media .avi file by default. They are a bit big, but you can go to zamzar.com and convert to any file type you want, for free. I have started converting to .m4v (iPod) because the examples can then be downloaded to kids iPods and iPhones. The nice thing about zamzar is that once you upload your .avi file, they email you when the file is converted. It usually takes a matter of 10 minutes or so.
ReplyDeleteThe great thing about this setup is that you don't need a tablet PC. You can either write directly on your SmartBoard or you can use a wireless tablet like the Smart Airliner or the Qomo board that I use.
I really like your video, its clear and easy to follow.. Thanks
ReplyDelete